Redshirts by John Scalzi

So, Redshirts, the new John Scalzi novel. Okay. Hmmm.

Look, I’m a fan of Scalzi’s fiction. His Old Man’s War books are excellent SF with a good story, setting, and plenty of humour in the narrative that works well. Agent to the Stars was also a really good read, as was Fuzzy Nation. But Redshirts. Man, disappointing isn’t even the word.

redshirtsThe focus of Redshirts is the UUC Intrepid, and some newly arrived ensigns – our titicular Redshirts. The primary character is Andrew Dahl, and it’s his experiences as he joins the Intrepid that we follow. There’s something very wrong on this ship, and with his colleaugues miraculously disappearing at the right moments just as senior officers walk into the room, Dahl soon sets about to discover just what the hell is going on. It appears that there’s a rather high percentage of crew deaths on away missions, and it is clear that certain people seem to be invulnerable to this misfortune….

I’ll start with the good: Redshirts is a funny novel, a quick read, and full of references to Star Trek. I enjoyed reading it, plowing through in barely a day, simply because it’s a typical Scalzi novel and his prose is easy to read – it very much has the ‘one more chapter’ effect. I also very much liked the fact that Redshirts focused on the minor crew members on the Intrepid, not on the bridge crew and high-ranking officials as is the case with many novels, and TV shows.

However.

Despite how much I enjoyed reading Redshirts I got the feeling, on pretty much every page, that I’d seen this before. Scalzi pays homage to Star Trek, without a doubt, and manages to do so fairly well, but that’s its biggest failing. It’s too similar, too many plot elements have been seen before. Adding a tongue-in-cheek take on them is good because, lets face it, the source material is ripe for mocking. But Redshirts’ main draw is also its biggest letdown.

I had very high hopes for Redshirts, but ultimately it failed for me on pretty much all counts. It’s a quick – and enjoyable – read, but doesn’t do well when you look below the superficial elements. And the Codas – completely unnecessary, and it felt like they were there simply as padding because the main story was over so quickly.

For a bit of mindless reading if you’ve a spare afternoon, then Redshirts should suit you fine, but if you’re looking for something deeper just give it a miss. I can’t say I recommend it, because I don’t, I’d much rather direct you to his previous novels where you’ll find some of the most enjoyable SF stories I’ve read.

5 thoughts on “Redshirts by John Scalzi”

  1. I'm torn on this book. It has his usual fast paced feel to it, but it lacked the emotional kick that all his other books seem to have. Still a good book though. I actually was laughing out loud during many scenes in this book.

  2. Yes…and no. I have to agree that the codas were rather disappointing. But even though it is just a fun, light read, it's worth recommending. I too was laughing at many parts of the book.

  3. I'm in the same boat. I love, LOVE Scalzi's fiction. I hadn't been disappointed at all with what I'd read up until reading this. I didn't hate it, and it had its fun moments, but maybe I was just expecting more because from all the hype, especially driven by the author, this one just didn't deliver. The joke wore thin early, the juvenile sex references didn't work in the story and felt forced and unnecessary, and it wasn't as satisfying as I would have hoped after waiting for awhile for a new Scalzi novel.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *