Reviewed by Stephen Aryan
As you might expect with a book that starts at the end of someone’s life, a portion of the story will revolve around what came before. The main part of the novel is focused on what recently happened to Harry, but what I wasn’t expecting and was delighted by was the call-backs to very early moments, characters and places that were scattered throughout the book. I’m a fairly big fan of the series and I spotted a few moments of serendipity, but I’m sure there are probably some less obvious Easter eggs for the super fans out there.
After 12 novels and an anthology, I have a fairly good idea of who Harry Dresden is. We already know a fair amount about his difficult and troubled childhood, but in Ghost Story we find out about an event that was an important crossroads from his past. This event shaped Harry, it put him on the path that led him to becoming the man we all know. It could have gone very differently and he could have given in to his darker nature and become the sort of pupil Justin DuMorne always wanted. It was perhaps one of the most important moments from his childhood that we didn’t know about, until now. This is just the first of many touches that make this a truly remarkable book and a fantastic series. In the last couple of books there have been lots of pay-offs for long time readers and there were a few more in Ghost Story.
Harry is gone, but the world has not stopped turning, the monsters have not packed up and gone away just because he is no longer in the fight. It was very satisfying to see the long-term effects Harry has had on those around him in the city. But his legacy goes far beyond the people he personally saved, and even though the story is still told from Harry’s perspective, there were some scenes where he was just an observer. People spoke about him without knowing he was there which often left Harry surprised by how others saw him. It was quite an eye opening experience that I think will affect him to a small degree in the future.
A good portion of time has elapsed since Harry’s sudden departure at the end of Changes. This means we, and Harry, are playing catch up and need to get up to speed on what’s happened to his city. His friends have been badly affected by his absence, some more so than others, but they’ve reached a place where they can still move forward together. Life is much harder without him around, some difficult choices and unsettling decisions have been made, but they were deemed necessary at the time. He might not agree but he has to accept them, because he can’t affect events anymore. As expected this makes it incredibly frustrating and painful for Harry to see his friends suffering and have no way of helping them. Once again this novel shows that creating realistic and well rounded characters, that you deeply care about, is one of Butcher’s greatest skills as a writer.
As much as Changes was a turning point for the series, Ghost Story is a turning point for Harry and many of the main cast. Events large and small have changed the characters over a dozen books and I loved seeing how they have grown up over the years and evolved. Some of these changes have been painful and irreversible, but it made the story all the more rewarding for the loyal reader.
The stories from this point forward in future novels will not be the same. The series could not have kept going in the same vein indefinitely without trying to top itself with every new book, and it would have become ridiculous. Ghost Story is a sort of interlude for reflection before we start a new chapter in the ongoing series.
The last three books before Ghost Story were building towards something epic, which we saw in Changes, where events came to a head and Ghost Story deals with the fallout, global and local. Over the last few books Harry has continued gaining power as well as acquiring new abilities and allies. One thing that became apparent in Ghost Story was that his approach to dealing with people and conflict has changed. He isn’t a shoot first, ask questions later guy, but he has moved a little more in that direction of late. Being rendered powerless brought this to light and I believe that in the future we will see a different Harry, one changed in his approach, because up to now he has always been fairly short sighted.
If he sees someone getting beaten up he will just wade in, no questions asked. That’s not enough anymore. Harry is playing a very different sort of game now. He’s been the fulcrum of too many events, he’s friendly or involved with too many significant powers to fade into the background. He’s a major player now, whether or not he likes it or wants to be. The stakes are much higher, the consequences much more far reaching and he’s now responsible for a lot of other people. He hates the Merlin for being a big picture guy, for being someone will sit and do nothing while a few people suffer because in the long run it may save hundreds. I don’t think Harry will quite be that cold and calculating, but I think he will be someone who treads more carefully and who thinks about the big picture and the long-term effects of his actions.
What all of this added up to for me was another extremely emotional and a very rich reading experience. Butcher rewards his readers, he trust them and doesn’t try to short change them, but he also doesn’t tie up everything in a neat bow at the end of any novel. Actions have consequences, characters die and don’t come back, good people turn bad, the bad can be redeemed and deals with devils don’t come cheap. The world is made of grey, but Harry is someone who does his best to see it in black and white. He doesn’t always succeed in his missions, despite his best attempt, as we see a few times in Ghost Story, but that will never stop him trying. That’s just who he is and that’s why he’s had such a huge impact on so many people.
The Dresden Files is a consistently gripping and extremely well written and addictive series. I think it is the best urban fantasy series being published and I am always desperate to read the next volume and just need to know what happens next. I’ve been living with these characters for over ten years, and have read more adventures about them than any other series of novels on my bookshelf. I keep coming back for so many reasons, the characters are fascinating and well rounded, the stories are amazing, pacy and gripping, they’re incredibly inventive and Butcher does a great job of taking myths and folklore and turning them into something completely his over. These aspects and many others add up to make a great series.
Butcher’s success and loyal fan base is well deserved and the books have actually been getting better, richer and more rewarding. Changes was the end of one major chapter, and Ghost Story is the start of what comes next, but the story of Harry Dresden is far from over and I can’t wait to see happens next. If you’re not reading this series and you enjoy urban fantasy then you’re missing out on something brilliant.
Great review! I agree 100% with your description of Harry and the series. The Dresden Files is one of the best urban fantasy series I've ever read (the Joe Pitt Case Books by Charlie Huston is another excellent series). Jim Butcher somehow manages to raise the bar with every new book, which is no mean feat.
I love that everyone in the books evolves and changes over time. They feel real. Butcher also has a knack for writing animal characters. Mister and Mouse are as interesting and complex as the human characters. I would love it if Butcher wrote some more scenes where Mouse has a voice.
I received Ghost Story on my Kindle but as I'm currently engrossed in A Dance With Dragons, I haven't had a chance to read it yet. But it's next on my list!
Finally, a big thank you for this site. I've been introduced to many authors and books through reading your reviews. I unhesitatingly recommend Walker of Worlds to anyone who asks. Great job guys!
Hi Odette,
Thank you for the kind words and I'm glad you enjoyed my review. I absolutely adore so many of Butcher's characters, and ignoring Harry my favourites have to be Murphy, Molly and Michael. They're all so great though and I also love Mister and Mouse.
A Dance with Dragons, yes indeed, I'll be reading that at some point, although I'm not going to rush as it will be a while before the next one so I won't have to play catch up!
Steve
Solid review: I am amazed with Butcher's skill; Check out my review: http://bit.ly/nFJ8EC
So I've read a number of reviews on the Dresden files and they sound right up my alley. I was walinking through a bookstore and they had Turn Coat in HB for 3.50. Picked it up of course, but now my question: should I read the books in order, or just give turn coat a whirl? Ge erally I read seres from beginning to end in chronologcal order.
This comment has been removed by the author.
You should definitely read the series from the start. Each book is a standalone story, however, threads are carried forward, and larger story arcs build in the background, so the pay offs later for long time readers are very shocking and amazing. Definitely start at the beginning. By the time you get to Turn Coat it will mean that much more.