This is a topic that I’m sure many people will have an opinion on, but here’s mine: I think negative reviews should be written. You may ask why, and the answer is simple: reviews should not be for the sole purpose of praising a novel.
I’m the first person who wants to shout about books I enjoyed, and I think positive reviews (and mostly positive) are a valuable resource for fans, especially when the reviews they read are from sources they both trust and have similar reading tastes to. I follow a fair amount of reviewers myself, and while not all have the same taste as me in books, they’re all ones that I trust. Of course, this doesn’t always mean that their opinion is the same as mine, but more often than not it is the case – both the positive and negative.
What brings me to this topic today is fairly straight forward. Yesterday my review of Adam Christopher’s latest novel, The Burning Dark, went live over at SFFWorld.com, and it’s not a positive one. In fact, it’s almost completely negative. I make one comment on how some scenes hit the mark, but other than those it just didn’t work for me in any way, shape, or form. I won’t repeat myself, but if you want to read it you can do over here.
So what, exactly, is the point of a negative review? Well, the same as a positive one, in my opinion. Some people may want to read it, others may ignore it – that’s just the way it goes. There’s also the point about promoting reviews, and whether negative reviews should be promoted. This is more tricky to answer because, yes, they should be, but not in the same way. I think the main difference, for me, is that I want to shout about positive reading experiences, but not so much about negative ones. I want people to know that I’ve written a review, but I won’t be as vocal if it is negative.
I rarely finish a book if I’m not enjoying it, so for me a negative review is not a common occurrence. But when I do finish books that leaves me unimpressed I’m going to say something, just as I do when I finish a book that I’ve thoroughly enjoyed.
I think it’s all very much each to their own, but if negative reviews aren’t written the perception to fans is rather skewed.