Reviewed by Stephen Aryan
This is a second book in a trilogy and I really enjoyed the first. So I approached this volume with great excitement and was really looking forward to it, but on the whole I thought it was uneven and I was disappointed at the end. Some spoilers for the first book will be included, so look away now if you don’t want to know. When Way of the Shadows ends, Kylar is setting off to live a new life with Elene and a surrogate daughter. Durzo is dead and Logan, the once and future king, is a prisoner in the worst place on earth and not likely to survive for more than a few days. But Kylar doesn’t know this, thinks his friend is dead, and therefore isn’t going to come and rescue him. As cliff-hangers go, it doesn’t get any better than that.
So imagine my surprise when the first approximately two hundred pages of the second book felt like a day time soap opera. It was full of teenage level angst as Kylar tries to move forward in his relationship with Elene, but there is a lot of fumbling, emotionally and physically, between them. Kylar is a bit of a mess psychologically, and it’s not surprising after first living rough on the streets doing whatever was needed in order to survive, and then being apprenticed to an assassin. So his idea of relationships and a normal life are not familiar concepts. So to some degree the character is immature, despite the fact that he has killed people. It was always going to be a struggle for him to adapt, but for me it was not handled very well as it went on too long and it felt very at odds with the other threads.
An interesting story thread was Logan’s continued survival in The Hole, but we are also introduced to some new characters and previously tertiary characters were brought forward into the spotlight. I commented in my review of the first book that it was unpredictable with lots of twists and turns which I really enjoyed. I believe the author was trying for that again in this volume, but for me it never quite achieved it on the same level, and in the end it felt a bit jumbled. To be fair there were a number of unexpected events that I never saw coming which kept me reading and it was never a predictable read. At no point did I say, well obviously so and so will die, and she’ll end up with that one, and they’ll live happily ever after. This book is very dark, so all bets are off and as proven in the first book and again this one, no character is safe. Weeks takes a number of risks in terms of plot and character development and I feel that he was mostly, but not always, successful.
In the second half of the book the action really picks up again when Kylar is forced out of his new life and must return to his old. It is something he was unable to leave behind for a number of reasons, including the manner in which he was raised, but also because he is now heir to a remarkable artefact that effectively grants him immortality. At this point the story threads start to converge and characters that were previously running in parallel start to interact with one other. There is a resolution at the end of this book, some story threads are tied up, but it feels very much like a chapter in Kylar’s life and not the end of his story. Some new plot threads are left dangling to be picked up in the third book and the finale was interesting, but parts of it left me puzzled. A previously important character was relegated to a supporting role until the latter part of the book and given very little do, which was another surprise, but not a good one this time.
There are a lot of interesting ideas in this book, new angles on familiar archetypes which demonstrate the author’s creativity, so Weeks cannot be accused of writing a fantasy story by the numbers. Sometimes a middle book in a trilogy can suffer from being flat and treading water until the finale in the series, and again that is not the case here. There is a lot of action and plot twists, but compared to the first it lacked clarity and focus. I think character development was flat and incredibly juvenile in some places, and fascinating in others, especially the character of Logan. I hope in the last book there will be a chance to see the long term repercussions of his incarceration, because they will have left an indelible mark.
I am intrigued and still want to know what happens next to the characters and I will be reading the third book in the trilogy, but I will be approaching it with a fair amount of trepidation. I hope it returns to form and is more tightly written like the first, with more adult dialogue and less modern day slang which was distracting and ineffective. This book hasn’t put me off the author or the series. As ever, this is just my opinion so let me know your thoughts.