Reviewed by Stephen Aryan
This is the second fabulous outing for Brenda and Effie in Whitby, England’s answer to Sunnydale. Whitby sits on top of the Bitch’s Maw, which sounds much worse than the Hellmouth of Buffy fame, but is more or less the same. Whitby, like the bubbly blonde Slayer’s town of Sunnydale, is full of all manner of ghostly, ghastly and creepy things that come out to play at night. But instead of the Slayer, the monsters must face a dangerous duo of old biddies who regularly battle the supernatural.
Something Borrowed continues the deliciously funny, evil, and twisted stories that mash together a slew of different genres to create something utterly unique and compelling. The stories are a blend of folklore, inspiration taken from 20th century fiction, movies and TV shows, as well as lots of original material. The end result is something that is full of many Easter eggs for those in the know, but even if you don’t pick up on all of them, it’s just an incredibly rich playground. All of the Brenda and Effie books are very tightly written and yet I am always drawn into them quickly and can easily picture the characters and setting.
This novel digs a bit more into Brenda’s past and we get to see one of her previous adventures from before she came to Whitby that comes full circle, linking it to an event in the present. It’s difficult to do a review without a bit of a spoiler about one of the main characters so look away now if you don’t want to know. You were warned.
So, given that Brenda is the Bride of Frankenstein, and has lived for almost two hundred years, the scope for stories about her past is huge and incredibly intriguing. She’s lived dozens of different lives over the years, from highborn lady to working class servant, and when an old friend from her past turns up, who should rightfully be dead, you know there’s a story there. Her longevity is a result of her creation, making her very unique, so it’s rare for her to see other people from previous lives. As Brenda and Effie try to make sense of the weirdness in the present with help from her old friend, Henry, the story about how he is still alive is bubbling along under the surface and eventually revealed. As ever its fascinating, clever and very funny. I don’t want to keep referring to it, but Buffy is a very good touchstone because as well as being a drama, it could seamlessly move into a comedy and then into a harrowing scene, and it’s exactly the same here. Some of the supernatural crimes Brenda and Effie investigate are pretty nasty, but the deaths and the violence is never graphic. You’re also very likely to find the next scene could be something hilarious which stops the book from becoming a depressing read. Always entertaining, always moving forward, neat and tidy, much like Brenda’s Bed and Breakfast.
The whole book, and indeed the series for me, is such a pleasure to read and Something Borrowed ended on such a cliff-hanger, it paved the way for the third in the series which I am now desperate to read. Overall it’s a fabulous addition to the series and I would highly recommend it if you enjoy a book with a good mix of drama and comedy, with plenty of supernatural elements too.