Reviewed by Stephen Aryan
This is the second of three standalone novels by Joe Abercrombie set in the same world as his previous First Law Trilogy. Chronologically it takes place after First Law and Best Served Cold. You can read this book independent of any of the others and it will make sense, but several of the main characters have appeared in his other novels, so there are some very nice easter eggs for long time readers. There are also references to historic figures, people long dead that have become iconic and their feats legendary, but in the First Law we met them when they were just men trying to survive. At it’s core, that’s what this book is about – a fight for survival. It’s those who come after that make up stories and inflate the facts to create new heroes and legends to inspire the next generation.
There is a wealth of grey, as there always is in a Joe Abercrombie book, because he doesn’t make it easy for the reader by saying these characters are bad and these are good. It’s more realistic that way and true to life, and while some characters act in a way we might describe as evil, each believes they are doing the right thing for the greater good. I like it when an author doesn’t lay out every single little detail for you, in essence force feeding you the story and telling you who to cheer for and who to boo, like actors in a pantomime. There were certain characters in The Heroes I couldn’t stand and others I really liked but I’m positive my choices will differ from many other readers, which is as it should be. The story isn’t open for discussion, but it’s up to each individual to make up their own mind about the characters.
There were quite a few characters to keep track of but once I got into the story I had no trouble remembering who all of them were. There is a handy guide at the front of the book though together with a lovely map. Abercrombie’s unique descriptions and characterisation helped a great deal with keeping track and the dialogue was not interchangeable, so I always knew who was speaking. Just as we had in the First Law, one of the main characters, Gorst, has an internal monologue, which was absolutely hilarious and very telling. The disparity between what was said and what he was thinking in any given situation is no doubt extremely accurate to real life, but its also not for the sensitive as no punches were pulled. But then again, this whole book is not one for those who are easily offended as it is about a very violent battle over three days where a lot of blood is spilled.
Another element I’ve realised is common in Abercrombie’s books is that none of his characters are who they appear to be and their final destinations aren’t obvious. From chinless Generals with no common sense to the farm boys who dream of becoming great warriors. You can’t map what will happen to each character which makes for interesting and unpredictable reading. There is truth in every situation though, so none of the characters acted in a way that made me think it was done to serve the plot and was out of character.
A previous issue I had with the misery in Best Served Cold, which I enjoyed but didn’t feel it was his strongest work, was addressed in The Heroes. There was also a certain level of bleakness to The Heroes, which is not unexpected given that it’s about a reasonably realistic battle with lots of death, but it was well balanced with humour and I enjoyed the destination as much as the journey. There was an ending, not a happily ever after, but a nice bookend to events that left me satisfied with some events and character arcs coming full circle.
Overall I really enjoyed this book and would highly recommend it. It had both an epic and grand scale with huge battles, but it was also told from a very local perspective at times. We saw the battle from the top, with Generals and the King of the North planning out their moves like chess players, and we experienced it what it was like on the front like with new raw recruits and veterans, fighting in the mud, hip deep in entrails. With only a vague hint of some magic here and there, I can see why my local supermarket had a little reader guide saying, ‘If you Bernard Cornwell, give this a try!’ A gripping and exciting read with excellent characters and plenty of blood. What more could you ask for?