Reviewed by Stephen Aryan
This story takes place in the middle of a whole bunch of other X-men comics and it does help to know what’s going on in current continuity, although it’s not essential. So even though this is not a Gateway Comic by any stretch of the imagination, I wanted to review it because it does something we’ve been waiting for in comics for many years. The story has moved on and there’s no going back. I should point out this comic was not the first to do this and is not the only one. It used to be that in many comics, like episodes of early Star Trek TNG, the reset button was pressed and everything went back to normal. The phrase ‘nothing will ever be the same again’ was used so many times in comics it lost all meaning. However, in the last, maybe ten years or so, things have changed and have not gone back.
Charles Xavier dreamed of mutants peacefully living alongside humans while Magneto knew the two could never co-exist and wanted to see mutants take their place as rulers and inheritors of the Earth. The age of both of these men has now passed and in Nation X, the children have grown up and kicked the adults out of the nest. Scott Summers aka Cyclops was one of the original five mutants created by Stan Lee. These five students would eventually become the X-men and in many ways Cyclops was the leader. For decades Charles Xavier led and directed the X-men but in recent years he fell out of favour by making some bad decisions and his X-men lost faith in him.
In Nation X, Cyclops has come of age. He is now the leader of the X-men and head of the mutant nation of Utopia. After years of standing in the shadows and following orders like a good soldier, he is now the leader he was born and trained to be. Xavier and even Magneto now take their direction from him and whenever Xavier tries to take the back the reigns, Cyclops is quick to remind him he is no longer in charge and if he doesn’t like it he can go elsewhere. They don’t trust Xavier, but Cyclops has always done the right thing and he has grown up to become a tough general, the man Xavier always wanted him to become.
It was very enjoyable to see the story come full circle with Magneto having to prove his worth and sincerity to work with the X-men instead of against them after decades of being in opposition. He is a ruthless man but also very intelligent and he knows that his time has past and he is not the one who will shape the destiny of the mutants. Xavier is less willing to accept a secondary role but he too must earn their trust and goodwill as his mistakes are not easily forgotten or forgiven.
This trade was full of action with a few fights against dangerous enemies, but more interesting for me was to see how the character dynamics have changed. Magneto might be one of the most powerful mutants, but he is also not a young man anymore and he can’t push himself as hard as he used to without consequences. For those who read Joss Whedon’s run on Astonishing X-men there is a brilliant scene in Nation X which I can’t talk about even slightly without spoiling it, but this comic was worth reading just for that. Xavier is still a powerful telepath but now there are others that can fulfil that role equally well, so he is left to provide wise counsel, if it is required and asked for. Magneto and Xavier didn’t see their dreams fulfilled and now is the time of their children and grandchildren to reach for new dreams and they are no longer the shepherds of mutantkind.
Under the leadership of Cyclops, Utopia is to become an independent nation, a sovereign state within the borders of the United States. So in some ways it embraces both the visions of Magneto and Xavier. The X-Men still fight against enemies that threaten mutants and humanity, but they live apart and will self govern themselves. Creating a viable state is not easy and there are obviously those in opposition to the idea and we see some of the political wrangling that goes on behind the scenes. Cyclops must juggle all of this as leader, solving major problems like preventing an invasion of Utopia to minor issues, such as making sure enough electricity if generated to power the island.
Overall Nation X is fascinating look at leadership and the pressure placed on those in charge. If you’ve not read the X-men comics in a long time, then I would recommend getting up to date via Wiki or another summary website and diving back in, because for once, things have changed and there is no way things will ever be the same again.