Criminal: The Sinners by Ed Brubaker & Sean Phillips

Reviewed by Stephen Aryan

Criminal’s most popular character, Tracy Lawless, returns in The Sinners! It’s been a year since Tracy was forced into working for the bad guys, and now made men are turning up dead all over the city, in what appears to be mob-style hits. But since criminals don’t go to the cops for justice… only Tracy can solve this crime.

criminal-the-sinnersThis is the fifth volume of the excellent crime series by Ed Brubaker and Sean Phillips. If you’ve never read Criminal before you can still pick this up. Each trade paperback is a standalone story, but if you’ve read the others there are easter eggs, recurring characters and locations, and the whole thing starts to build up into a tapestry with threads from different stories being interwoven with one another.

This is the second outing of Tracy Lawless, a man who originally went AWOL from the army to find out who killed his brother and to get some revenge. Now he’s stuck working for a man he can barely tolerate, being asked to do things he really doesn’t agree with, but that was the price to pay off his debts. In many ways the character has become just like his father, and that’s a bad thing in this case, since he hates his father and everything about him.

Tracy is also in a lot of trouble. He’s biting the hand that feeds him, standing out and causing problems when he really can’t afford to. He should stay quiet, get on with the job and keep his head down, but he can’t help it. Something in him won’t break, he has a code that he just can’t let go of, a bizarre sense of honour, and as a result he can’t do everything that is asked of him. His boss, Mr Hyde, considers just giving him the bullet and getting rid of a problem, but instead he tasks Tracy with solving another pain in his rear. Someone is killing people all over town, criminals and informants, and there seems to be no rhyme or reason for it and he tasks Tracy with finding out who is responsible it and putting a stop to it.

What unfolds is a very morally ambiguous and gritty crime drama where every character is a murky shade of grey. Tracy isn’t a private detective, he isn’t trained for it and so mistakes are made along the way. He is trying to dig himself out of a hole, but he keeps making it worse, going off on the wrong track, stirring up a hornet’s nest, but then that’s what makes it all the more realistic. He isn’t a perfect suave private eye or super-soldier who’s stronger or better trained than everyone else. He’s just a guy, trying to put things right and find a way to get by. I’m sure that doesn’t sound sexy, but this isn’t a standard comic by any stretch of the imagination. It’s a dark, tense, clever, witty and adult story, with lots of black humour. If you’re a fan of crime films in general, if you enjoy anti-heroes and stories with double-dealing, with plenty of plot twists and no clear black or white hat characters, then this is for you.

I don’t really want to compare it in style to any TV crime series, because most of them are too glossy, cheesy and focused on the actors getting lots of screen time and great one liners rather than the story. However, if you enjoyed The Wire, and imagine that the story is completely focused on the crime side, then Criminal is a distant cousin. The dialogue in Criminal is always tight, fitting with the style and on the nose, and after reading this I can understand why it won in 2007 and has since been nominated again for two Eisner Awards in 2010.

The Eisners are the comic book equivalent of the Oscars, or BAFTAs, and it is very unusual for a small comic like this to win, but it indicates how highly it is regarded in the industry and the quality of the book. I say it’s a small comic because it won’t be at the top of the US comic charts every month, because it doesn’t have superheroes in it, or superpowers of any kind for that matter. Nevertheless there is a huge worldwide following for this series, and really good crime comics in general, are sadly few and far between. Fans of the series that have provided introductions include Scottish crime author Ian Rankin, Tom Fontana, creator and writer of OZ and Homicide: Life on the Streets, comics writer and creator Frank Miller and Ken Bruen, the writer of amongst other things, the novel London Boulevard, which was adapted into a little movie called The Departed. This is a great comic with a fantastic creative team who have now been working together for a while and are constantly producing unique and brilliant comics. I highly recommend you take a look at Criminal, and Sleeper, an earlier series.

If you’re read all of the five Criminal trades and are desperate for something similar in the meantime, then I would suggest looking at Ed Brubaker’s one time writing partner, Greg Rucka. The two of them worked together on Gotham Central and it is a great character focused series about the cops of Gotham City. Alternatively you could try Greg Rucka’s new series, Stumptown, from Oni Press about a female private investigator who gets herself into a lot of trouble while trying to solve what sounds like an easy case.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *