The Lies of Locke Lamora by Scott Lynch

Reviewed by Stephen Aryan

The Lies of Locke Lamora by Scott Lynch is a book I took a gamble on. At the time of purchase I’d never heard of the author or anything about the series. I saw it in the new releases section of the SFF bit of my local bookshop, read the back cover and bought it. Now, a few years later, I’m very glad I did because Scott Lynch is one of the most interesting new fantasy authors I’ve read in a long time. For me, he and Joe Abercrombie, helped to reinvigorate my interest in the genre and their novels urged me to go out and look for other new authors with unique voices. I never stopped reading fantasy, and there have been some amazing books in the last ten years, but they were not books that pushed the boundaries or created new sub-genres of their own, which I saw with both Abercrombie and Lynch. Ok, enough preamble. You get the idea that this is something different.

the-lies-of-locke-lamoraThe Lies of Locke Lamora takes place in a Venice-like city, called Camorr, in what has been described as an analogue of 19th century Italy. It’s a fair shorthand assessment, but it also doesn’t tell you anything about some of the incredibly creative ideas crammed into this book which I’ll come on to. For a debut book it surprised me, not only at how different it was, but also how accomplished. Lynch, like some of his fantasy brethren, is a long time fan of the genre, a self confessed gamer, role-player and geek. He has created a setting without monsters, inhuman races or any familiar fantasy tropes, and if not for some of the magic and alchemy found in the story, it could almost be a historical novel taking place in some weird parallel world. His style is not overly descriptive, but where he has introduced something new he takes the time to give you just enough detail to frame it in your mind without it being a burden. Later in the story he might revisit such a piece of technology or monument in the city and add a few more flourishes, but an air of mystery always remains which kept me intrigued. In particular were the Elderglass towers and objects. Camorr was essentially built on the ruins of an older city, one created by a race of people long dead and forgotten in the annuls of history and the only thing left behind are buildings and sometimes small items that cannot be fathomed or copied. The story is not about the mystery of this forgotten race, it focuses very much on the characters living in the present, but it does add an interesting touch to the landscape. For all the accomplishments by magi and alchemists in the story, who appear to be some of the most powerful, respected and feared people in society, it is a reminder to everyone that they are still inferior in their knowledge to those who came before them. It is a very interesting backdrop. They are standing on the shoulders of giants and they are lacking.

Locke is an orphan and the story begins where he is taken in by a kindly old man who looks after street urchins. Comparisons to Oliver Twist at this point are fair as the old man is very much like Fagin, someone who is not doing it out of the kindness of his heart. The Thiefmaker, as he is known, expects the children to steal in return for a roof over their head and food. Despite being very young, Locke is an exceptional thief, so much so that he steals from the wrong people and gets the Thiefmaker in trouble, more than he can deal with in fact. Unable to control Locke the Thiefmaker sells him to Chains, a priest of the nameless Thirteenth God, who runs a temple. In fact, the temple is a front and Chains is a master thief who takes in exceptional children and trains them to become con-artists and masters of confidence games who will steal from the rich and keep the spoils for themselves. Chains calls them the Gentleman Bastards, and they truly are, because this is not a story about Robin Hood wannabes who give to the poor. They are the poor, or they would be, if they didn’t help themselves to gold from the rich.

The story moves between the past, where we see some of Locke’s exploits as a boy, and the present where he is an adult and running his own crew to rob the aristocracy. These are people who Locke has grown up and together they are a peculiar family unit. They all have their strengths and they play to them in order to confound and steal money out from under the noses of those with plenty of gold but little sense. As a fantasy novel version of the TV show Leverage, or Hustle, it could have been enough to sustain the book for one or maybe two novels, but after the first couple of stories it would have become something very episodic, and therefore easy to put down. The larger part story that adds real texture to the novel is not only that of Locke’s life, gradually moving forward as a boy as we explore his history and relationships, but also one of political intrigue and underworld wrangling. The story is about the evolution of the characters and also how their actions, direct and otherwise, change the landscape of the city and the course of their lives.

As Locke and his team start working on a new elaborate con, a mysterious figure called the Grey King turns up in Camorr and starts killing senior figures in the criminal underworld. This disrupts the status quo, throwing the criminals into disarray but also upsetting Locke and his plans to rob the rich of all their gold. What follows is an unpredictable tale of him getting pulled into the crisis and being forced to put all of his skills as a con artist and manipulator to get him and his friends out of a tangled net of blackmail and deception. It is not nearly as easy as it sounds and the title of the book itself tells you something about the main character. There are some touches of magic, but those who wield it are few and far between and they are feared. The rise and fall of people in this book is mostly by the sword, or rather, a dagger in the back as the story involves thieves and street gangs.

With this debut Scott Lynch created something unique, an interesting story about the criminal underworld in a fantasy setting that was well crafted and original. Since then, and as mentioned in an earlier review, I have come across other underworld fantasy books with a criminal as the main protagonist, but so far I have not seen any quite the same as this. This is not a story about a grey character setting out to find redemption for all his previous sins, nor is it about a broody miserable murderer who is just misunderstood. For all the darkness, murder and mayhem in the book it’s a fun action romp with real heart.

Two other great strengths of Lynch worth mentioning are his characters and the sense of humour found throughout the story. At times Lies, is an incredibly dark story, with some horrible moments, but with all of the conning, trickery and scheming, sometimes it is very funny. Not slapstick humour or forced humour where every character in the room laughs for some reason that isn’t obvious and isn’t actually funny. This book made me laugh out loud and at other times I was very worried for the characters because I was emotionally invested in their future. Locke and his team are very well rounded people and over the course of each book you find out a little bit more about them with the flashback sequences. You want them to succeed and beat their enemies, but I was also very aware of their line of work and that in the brutal and harsh world, not everyone is likely to make it out alive.

The Lies of Locke Lamora is the first of seven planned books in the series about the Gentleman Bastards. The second book, Red Seas Under Red Skies is a radical departure from the first, but it does feature some of the same characters, and while it builds on the first novel it is a standalone story like the first. The first two books came out fairly quickly and they were exceptionally well received and with very good reason. Critically acclaimed is a phrase thrown around quite often nowadays, but in my opinion it is well deserved in this case as I have not read anything like it within the fantasy genre since. It sits alongside other books in the fantasy section of a bookshop, but it is a unique animal. There was a delay between the second and third book, but I am very happy to say that the third book in the series is now scheduled for release in 2011.

With three of the biggest and most eagerly awaited fantasy books being released this year, those being The Wise Man’s Fear by Patrick Rothfuss, The Heroes by Joe Abercrombie and The Republic of Thieves by Scott Lynch, I think 2011 is going to be an amazing year for the fantasy genre.

4 thoughts on “The Lies of Locke Lamora by Scott Lynch”

  1. Scott Lynch is one of my favorite authors. It's hard to believe this book was a debut, let alone from someone who was so young when he wrote it.

    Lies of Locke Lamora is just brilliant. pure, unadulterated fun and brilliant. and YES, you hit it right on the head, the reader will have an emotional investment in these characters by the end, and it continues through book 2. Making you really care about the welfare of a character, isn't that the hallmark of a good writer?

  2. I absolutely loved The Lies of Locke Lamora when I read it last year, and I'm currently reading Red Seas Under Red Skies, which is every bit as good if not better (so far anyway – I've still got about 100 pages to go). Glad to see that the 3rd book is coming this year!!

  3. Love the series, indeed, anxiously awaiting book 3!

    Also you can add to your list of upcoming books this year A Dance with Dragons by GRR Martin! Release date announced just today!

  4. Yes, Lies of Locke Lamora is great adventure fantasy. Second book is not that good, but also gives much fun. I'm waiting impatiently for Republic of Thieves. I hope that this book will be as good as previous Lynch novels.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *