Reviewed by Stephen Aryan
A series of apparent suicides rings alarm bells with the police. And before he knows it Harry Dresden, professional wizard, is hired to investigate. At the first crime scene he finds an unmistakable magical taint – and a message specially designed for him, referencing the killing of witches. Harry is desperate to hunt down his tormentor and halt the killings, but instead finds evidence implicating his half-brother, Thomas. To Harry, this just doesn’t add up, so he must add clearing his brother’s name to his expanding list. Something that didn’t make the list is subtlety, and Harry’s search attracts the attention of the White Court of vampires …Soon, whichever way he turns, he faces a power struggle that will render him outnumbered, outclassed and dangerously susceptible to temptation. And if he screws up, his friends will die.
This is book 9 in the Dresden files. Harry Dresden is changing. In this novel there is a crisis to avert and a puzzle to unravel involving something mystical and pretty grisly and unpleasant, but there is also the issue of what is eating Harry. I’ll avoid spoilers of this book, but if you’ve read the previous books up to this point then you will know that for a long time now Harry has been carrying around a passenger in his head. Lasciel is a fallen angel, a demon trapped in an old Roman coin buried under a load of concrete in his basement. Despite that prison, a part of Lasciel was able to get out and essentially attach itself to Harry’s mind with some nasty results. However, it’s not all been bad as Lasciel has helped him on occasion, but mostly from a standpoint of self preservation and because she wants to tempt Harry and show him how much he would benefit if he took up the coin and let her possess him properly.
This constant struggle and battle of wills has gone on for some time and it is one of the underlying causes of Harry’s growing anger issues. His long time friend and colleague Karrin Murphy mentions his temper, and even fellow Warden Ramirez notices it when Harry’s kills a ghoul in a particularly cold and calculated way. To be fair to Harry, it had just murdered someone and they went after it, but it was how he disposed of the ghoul and how detached he was from what he was doing that was most unsettling.
The war with the Red Court has been going on for some time, and of course Harry was essentially responsible for starting it in the first place. By this point in the story a lot of people have died and when Harry sees a couple of innocents end up as the latest casualties something snaps inside. I don’t think that he feels responsible for everything and for all the deaths, but then again he does take on a lot that is not always his fault. Whatever the root cause Harry becomes colder, harder, tougher and very dangerous. If it weren’t for his friends and family, I suspect he would have gone a lot further and done things much worse that he would have later come to regret. Harry Dresden is a good man, but he is also very human and those around him stop him from becoming, for lack of a better word, evil.
As ever in this story, Butcher’s characterisation shines throughout. Harry is now a teacher and mentor, and there are some nice Star Wars references, but, as much as he is a geek, Harry is also quick to point out the differences between fantasy and real life. He makes it clear to his apprentice that they don’t get second chances and they don’t get to die and come back as shiny ghosts. He keeps hammering away with this message at Molly because she isn’t listening and is still clinging to the idea that she knows best, despite all of her earlier mistakes. It’s another burden for him to carry, another weight around his neck and I think it is this, combined with the slaughter and ongoing war, plus the constant temptation of Lasciel and his unbearable loneliness that finally starts to get the better of him. But thankfully Harry is not completely alone.
When a string of murders across the city point towards his brother as the culprit, Harry refuses to believe it. After all that he has been through, especially the years of being an orphan and being raised by a wacko and trying to get out from under his shadow, he won’t believe his only kin is responsible. But as the evidence starts to mount up he is forced to make some very difficult choices, whilst trying to unravel what it is all for, as well as just who is responsible. As much as this a supernatural detective story, there is also a larger picture and it is tied into Harry’s life and the ongoing war.
This volume sees the return of the White Court of Vampires, the succubus and other emotion feeding vampires who Harry previously encountered. All of this is tangled up into one giant story and threads of it run back to the war with the Red Court. There are a few more hints dropped about a new mystery that Harry has been noticing, a conspiracy behind the curtain as it were, plus the quest for a new owner of the special sword Harry has inherited is touched on.
Without spoiling anything, this story sees the welcome return of an old friend of Harry’s and there are some other resolutions that tie up threads that had been left hanging. So as well as tackling the larger mystery, some of the weight Harry is carrying is eased from his shoulders. The war is still raging and they have not won by any stretch of the imagination, but I have a feeling that it cannot continue much longer as some powers which were previously sitting on the sidelines are now taking sides.
I read this book in two days, mostly because I was on holiday with few interruptions, but also because the story is incredibly lean and totally without fat or self indulgence by the author. The other reason is that it is a gripping read and is the sort of book you don’t want to put down and could potentially read in one sitting if time allowed. After nine books in a series that is not an easy feat to accomplish and I think it is worth mentioning as some long running series can become flat and repetitive. You couldn’t really read these books out of order, as each builds on the last, so rather than say each is better than the previous, I would say they are all consistently excellent.
One of the other things I admire about Butcher is that each volume is plotted out in a lot of detail beforehand and he manages to pack a lot in to each story, in terms of character and plot development. Some books I’ve read have had a similar style of pacing with cliffhangers at the end of each chapter, but they are so light on detail I never get a real feel for the characters or the setting. I prefer a good balance, where it’s not just all plot and explosions, whereas I know some people just want character development and the actual plot is less important. Others want the opposite, lots of kapow action to keep them going, and are happy to skimp on the internal stuff. For me Butcher manages to get the balance right, as by the end of the book I understand the White Court a little more, a few more secrets have been uncovered about Dresden, but also secondary and tertiary characters as well. One character who we have often seen, but rarely if ever speaks, gets a nice moment in the spotlight and normally I really dislike him, but in this book I sort of admired him at times.
White Night is a very accomplished book by a writer who has really hit his stride now and this series is far from tired and definitely not over. I had worried about the series starting to struggle under the weight of all the unresolved plots and outstanding issues, but White Night laid my concerns to rest. This isn’t like the TV show, Lost, adding layers and layers of mystery without ever giving any real answers. Answers are provided, plot points are resolved and there is the possibility of revisiting them in the future, but if it never happened you would be satisfied. I thoroughly enjoyed this book and can’t wait to read the next ones.